The swindle continues. A perfectly played reference to the ill-fated Sex Pistols 1980 movie The Great Rock’n’Roll Swindle. A remark worthy of John Lydon himself, filled with irony and condescension and maybe just a little admiration. Ironic, because punk was supposed to be cheap and disposable, but actually was complex and meaningful; condescending because how stupid were the public to shell out even more money for something so contrived; and admiring because goddammit, why hadn't I thought of that first?!
Savage debunks the notion that the Pistols were—as is a popular perception today—the *NSync of their day, a manufactured boy-band with about the same depth and relevance. McLaren was great at hindsight, saying "Oh, I meant that to happen" when really it was all out of control. Quite a bit of the book deals with the utter contempt and frustration with which Johnny Rotten and later Sid Vicious felt towards this Faginesque character.
30.10.76: I go see my first proper punk group. I know what it's going to be like: I've been waiting for years, and this year most of all: something to match the explosions in my head. The group are called the Clash; everybody I talk to says they're the best.... Within ten seconds I'm transfixed; within thirty, changed forever.
23.11.76...fascism here won't be like in
25.12.76: A party... in the kitchen downstairs, members of the Damned, the Clash and the Sex Pistols sit around a large table.... Halfway through the evening, the Heartbreakers arrive, and install themselves in a tight corner near the telephone, which Johnny Thunders uses to make hour-long calls to the
Savage covers the nascent punk scene in surrounding towns, such as the Buzzcocks in Manchester; the difficulty in getting clubs to book the bands; the sudden liberation (but not quite) young women felt, resulting in "stars" such as Siouxsie Sioux, Poly Styrene, and the Slits; the sometimes manufactured, sometimes quite real, competition between the Pistols and their rivals the Clash; the Pistols utterly disastrous tour of Southern America in 1978; the fashion, the art, the impact the movement had on the rigidly structured British class system. His account of the Jubilee summer (1977 was the 25th year of Queen Elizabeth's reign), and the attendant boat ride up the Thames when the Sex Pistols performed the incendiary "God Save the Queen," their inflammatory anti-royalty statement just as the boat passed Parliament, makes you realize that punk rock gave new meaning to "civil disobedience." Or, rather, just made it a hell of a lot more fun. Plus its hair looked fantastic.
And what of the tragedy at the heart of the original explosion of punk, the self-immolation of the notoriously doomed Sid Vicious and Nancy Spungen, still celebrated today in t-shirts and dolls and homemade Youtube videos? Savage is tender:
What happened next will always be a blur. In an account given by Vicious shortly before his death, he woke up from a Tuinol stupor in the light of the morning to find a trail of blood leading from a soaked bed to the bathroom.... he found Nancy lying under the sink with a hunting knife sticking in her side... Vicious went into complete shock--from which he would barely recover for the rest of his life. As the realization of what had occurred sank in, he panicked totally: the only person had ever cared for him was dead, by his knife, and he couldn't remember a thing.
What really put
Tattered, caustic icon Johnny Rotten is compared to the young French poet Arthur Rimbaud; the Clash wore Army fatigues splattered with brightly colored paint à la Jackson Pollock; Subway Sect and other dreary bands created music that seemed defiantly anti-music, almost musique concrète; and one cannot deny the primitive, art brut beauty of Xeroxed 'zines like Snffin' Glue, the flyers for shows and the record sleeves of hundreds of forgotten bands, all ransom-note graphics and ripped-up newspapers. Consider the brilliance of the 45 sleeve for the Sex Pistols' "Holidays in the Sun."
Punk rock might not be the monster it was so long ago, but it remains an oft-misunderstood musical genre, usually seen as one-dimensional, inarticulate, and musically incompetent, made by angry adolescents who have no regard for anyone but themselves. This all may be true, but to dismiss it as such is to miss a vital element of rock'n'roll: that is, that is rock’n’roll defined. Jon Savage’s work still stands as the great book on its subject, and one of the finest books on the sociology of music in general. Of course I didn't shell out $27.50 for it on that long-ago day, certainly not with Charles so willing and able to mock me. The book seemed weighty and deadening, a vampire leaching blood from the living. I didn't read it until the late '90s, when I was once again under the music's sway and decided it was time to see if there was something I could learn that I hadn't from the music itself.
Nothing kills punk rock like sincerity; its raison d'etre is mocking vitriol hurled at both one's enemies and oneself. England's Dreaming doesn't have any of that spitting, rabid energy of the best punk rock. It's not a “rock’n’roll book” in the sense that the other titan of punk literature, Please Kill Me, is, but they certainly belong on the shelf next to one another.